The ‘Babysitters Club’ Sketch That Never Made It On ‘SNL’ Sounds Amazing

'Late Night' host Seth Meyers has basically invented a new subset of trivia with a consistent question he likes to ask on his late night talk show: amazing 'SNL' sketches that never aired, no matter how much their creators loved them. Meyers has made it a (totally awesome) habit to ask other 'SNL' alums who hit his show what sketches they're most bummed about never making it on the air, and the results are so far incredible.

On last night's show, former 'SNL' writer Simon Rich stopped by to chat, and Meyers wasted no time asking Rich to tick off the one sketch he wishes had made it to the show. Rich was definitely ready to answer, immediately making note of a failed 'Babysitters Club' sketch that just didn't work -- oh, but we wish it would have.