Late Night’ host Seth Meyers’ Second Chance Theatre—a second home for the ‘SNL’ skits that never were—has so far given a playground to some wild stuff, but former ‘SNL’ star Jason Sudeikis had something a little more lo-fi in mind for his spin on the ol’ Second Chance-mobile. You can practically hear the pitch meeting: “It’s about a guy who wants to give juggling lessons, but everyone hates him.” Simple enough, right?

Oh, no, because "Juggling Flyer" somehow manages to capture the full range of human emotion—from anger and confusion to respect and affection—while telling a relatively simple story about a man who just wants to share his gifts with the world. As a special treat, ‘SNL’ writer Mike O’Brien also appears, along with former ‘SNL’ star Fred Armisen.