Whenever the women of SNL get to together make a music video, it tends to be the highlight of the show. The show’s female line-up is the strongest it has been in years (dare we say ever?) and their fearlessness is only matched by their comedy chops. Nothing is off limits and they‘re not afraid to embrace their femininity in ways that feels honest, insightful, and occasionally deeply weird. Like this sketch, which finds Kate McKinnon, Aidy Bryant, Cecily Strong, Vanessa Bayer, and guest host Elizabeth Banks singing all about the men who first turned them on when they were young girls.

The song itself is catchy and the video is a spot-on recreation of that ’90s pop music video look (complete with soft focus and overalls), but it’s the specificity of the whole thing that makes it work. You just know that someone involved in the creation of this sketch, whether it be the women on screen or the women in the writer‘s room, had similar feelings for some of the men mentioned here.

It’s a simple set-up: each woman sings about the pop culture figure that first, uh, awakened their womanhood back in the day. Some of the examples are obvious enough (Carson Daly and Taylor Hanson), while others take a turn into the weird (Mr. Sheffield from The Nanny and the Mendendez brothers). If you want to know Bryant’s first big crush, you’ll have to watch the video itself. It’s too good to spoil here.

More From ScreenCrush