'Homeland' Review: "In Memoriam"


Following last week's abrupt cliffhanger, 'Homeland' keeps the momentum going this week, and it looks like Saul is in some hot water with the CIA -- you guys might actually really like him when he's angry.

The only thing more interesting than Claire Danes' cry face is her "I was wrong" crazy-face, which we get a taste of when Quinn and the infantry are unable to find Nazir hiding out in the warehouse, but damn it, she knows he's still in there. This show -- and Claire Danes -- has done such brilliant work illustrating the manic highs and lows of Carrie's mind that it's so easy to believe she's right when everyone doubts her, and so easy to believe she's wrong, too. And each time her instincts are right, we're still surprised and able to cheer her on, but there's an undercurrent of sadness there, too -- on a hunch she goes back to the warehouse to search yet again, and she finds Abu Nazir. The cavalry comes in right after she gets knocked out, and before Nazir can pull something out of his jacket, he's shot down and killed.

It's a moment that could easily deflate the series because Nazir has been an integral part of the plot, and without him, there would be no Brody. But Nazir's death raises questions about Brody's future on the show and where the relationship with Carrie and the CIA could possibly go from here. Without Nazir, the CIA no longer needs Brody, and living happily ever after with Carrie just doesn't seem like the kind of thing 'Homeland' is interested in exploring. Yet, even with Nazir dead, there's no real sense of closure, even as Brody is trying to find it with Jessica -- they both know the marriage is dead and was long before Nazir was killed. As if to throw up a white flag and surrender to the end, Brody tries to tell Jessica the truth about the day when Elizabeth Gaines was shot, but it's too late -- she deserved to hear it before, but she doesn't need to hear it now.

It's such a relief to see the Brody marriage disintegrate after a long, exhausting season of these two circling the inevitable, and while I was personally cheering on the dissolution of their marriage for plot's sake, there's still something very sad and unsatisfying about their conversation in the car this week.

"In Memoriam" is filled with interrogations, from Quinn questioning Carrie after she escapes Nazir, to Carrie's failed interrogation of Roya Hamad, to Estes putting Saul through a polygraph test to force his resignation, and finally, Dana questioning her own father.

With Roya, Carrie thinks she may be able to connect with her on an emotional level, but Roya's not interested in female bonding. And even though she refuses to give up any information, it's that failed interrogation that pushes Carrie to return to the warehouse and find Nazir, so even though she doesn't know it, Roya technically did aid in the capture and murder of the man she was trying so desperately to protect. And though Roya's been kind of mediocre, acting mostly as plot facilitator, she was incredibly engaging and intriguing in the interrogation room -- all the more so when she started shouting in Arabic.

But back to Saul's lie detector test (hosted delightfully by guest star James Urbaniak) -- it's always fantastic to see him so fired up, and the idea that the very agency he's given his life to is now pushing him out feels frustrating, even from a viewer standpoint. Saul is such an even-keeled guy with a genuinely kind heart, and watching David Estes (who has become something of a villain and slightly cartoonish) pummel the loyalty out of Saul is depressing. Now that Saul knows that Estes has hired Quinn to kill Brody, Estes is using the only ammo he has -- Aileen's death -- against Saul to force him into early retirement. It's sad enough that Saul is being forced out of his job, but even sadder that they're using Aileen's death against him, when the last thing he wanted was to facilitate her death -- or anyone's, for that matter. Saul is not the killing type, and he honestly believes that there is good in everyone, so when he's asked if Aileen was a terrorist, his response is telling: "She said she was."

Filed Under: Claire Danes, Homeland, Showtime
Categories: TV News, TV Reviews
Leave A Comment

Recommended For You

Around the Web

Donald Trump Will Host SNL in November With Sia

by Kevin Fitzpatrick 43 minutes ago
NBC / Tom Pennington, Getty Images
Ever the human punchline, Donald Trump has braved some of his staunchest comedy critics in pursuit of the 2016 presidency. The blowhard billionaire even made headlines with which SNL player would tackle the role in Season 41, but all bets are off when “The Donald” himself hosts an upcoming November outing.

The Top Five Worst Jump Scares in Movie History

by Matt Singer an hour ago
In the tradition of ScreenCrush series like You Think You Know Movies and You Think You Know TV comes a new YouTube series: Top Five! Each week (or so; we’ve got a lot of other stuff going on), ScreenCrush editor and critic Matt Singer will count down a particular topic from the world of movies (and probably write these introductory posts in the third person).

‘Crimson Peak’ Star Tom Hiddleston on Playing Bad Guys, ‘Kong: Skull Island’ and His Love of Beyonce

by ScreenCrush Staff 2 hours ago
Tom Hiddleston, despite being an otherwise extremely pleasant and lovely human being, has a habit of playing some evil dudes. There’s Loki, from The Avengers, Adam from Only Lovers Left Alive, and now Thomas Sharpe in Guillermo del Toro’s Crimson Peak. What do directors see in this charming actor to cast him as an antihero? Is he secretly a monster? Does he hate Beyoncé and puppies? We caught up with Hiddleston recently to talk about Crimson Peak and to get to the bottom of this mystery.

Seth Rogen Shopping Another Garth Ennis Comic in ‘The Boys’

by Kevin Fitzpatrick 2 hours ago
We haven’t yet seen frame one of Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg’s AMC take on Garth Ennis’ infamous Preacher, and already the pair might have an eye on another notable comic adaptation. The Superbad duo might next shop an adaptation of Ennis’ superhero-policing The Boys, potentially for cable.

Robert Kirkman’s Cinemax ‘Outcast’ Gets Seriously Gross in First Clip

by Kevin Fitzpatrick 3 hours ago
Over the weekend, Walking Dead creator Robert Kirkman’s new Cinemax venture Outcast scared up a fresh trailer for its 2016 debut, but those in attendance of the New York Comic-Con panel were treated to something much more indicative of the show’s creep factor: Gird your stomachs, and have a gander at the unsettling first clip for Robert Kirkman’s Outcast.

Fox Lands Sci-Fi Disaster Script ‘Ascension’ for Matthew Vaughn

by Charles Bramesco 4 hours ago
Universal Pictures
Because the world contains a finite number of graphic novels written by Mark Millar, and because everyone’s gotta eat, money-in-the-bank filmmaker Matthew Vaughn is in the process of striking a deal with 20th Century Fox to direct a new project based on a fresh script that the studio purchased extra-specially for him.

‘12 Years a Slave’ Writer John Ridley Directing Feature About 1992 L.A. Riots

by Charles Bramesco 4 hours ago
Getty Images
Back in April, we reported that in-demand screenwriter John Ridley had been caught in Marvel’s web of cross-promotion, inking a deal to develop a TV show that would spin off a key property from the already-popular Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. program. The specifics of that project still have yet to take shape (though we’re all keeping our fingers crossed that the M.O.D.O.K. solo show America so richly deserves will soon come to pass), but today brings news of a new endeavor for Ridley with no less social import. The Academy Award-winning scribe of 12 Years a Slave has announced that he will take the director’s chair once again to helm a feature about the notorious 1992 Los Angeles riots catalyzed by Rodney King’s savage beating at the hands of the LAPD.

The Smoking Man Speaks in Stylish New Animated ‘X-Files’ Promo

by Kevin Fitzpatrick 17 hours ago
Earlier today we caught a few new looks at The X-Files’ 2016 return to follow the show’s appearance at New York Comic-Con, but at least one aspect of the legendary sci-fi series has been waiting in the wings. Take a look at FOX’s trippy new animated promo for The X-Files‘ return, which brings us one step closer to returning the infamous Cigarette Smoking Man.