Supernatural’ season 8 scares up its tenth episode of the season in mid-season premiere “Torn and Frayed,” as Sam and Dean must put aside their differences to help Castiel rescue the angel Samandriel (Tyler Johnston), while Sam is left with a difficult choice regarding Amelia (Liane Balaban).

Last month’s ‘Supernatural’ episode “Citizen Fang” saw Dean trying to exonerate Benny when Sam and Martin Creaser (Jon Gries) believed him responsible for a string of vampire murders, while Sam remembered dealing with the return of Amelia’s husband, so what does the latest season 8 episode bring?  Will the Winchesters finally be able to rid the world of Crowley’s demonic scum?

Read on for your in-depth recap of everything you need to know about ‘Supernatural’ season 8 episode 10, “Torn and Frayed!”

In an abandoned warehouse, a tortured Samandriel wills a spike to push its way out of his skull, allowing him to briefly summon Naomi for help. His efforts are interrupted however by a mysterious bow-tied demon doctor named Viggo, who menacingly places the spike back in his brain.

Back in Texas, Dean visits Sam’s hotel room to apologize for misleading him about Amelia’s safety, but Dean insists he was right about Benny's innocence.  Unsure how to resolve their current stalemate, the brothers part ways for the moment. Elsewhere, Castiel is summoned before Naomi, and given instructions to rescue Samandriel, before having his memories blanked again.

Castiel recruits Dean for the effort to Hastings, Nebraska, while Sam finds himself confronted again by Amelia at his hotel door. Sam apologizes for returning to her life, however briefly, and offers to get out of her way before the two rekindle their passion with a kiss. Meanwhile, Viggo continues to inflict pain on Samandriel, stumbling upon a torture with skull-embedded pins that forces Samandriel to involuntarily chant in Enochian, setting fire to a local town bush.

Dean and Cas pay a visit to a man hospitalized by the burning bush, who reveals that he heard it speaking a strange language. Castiel surmises that the effects of an angel’s scream would cause such phenomena, giving them a direction to search. Back at the hotel, Sam and Amelia resolve not to repeat their mistake, but rather take some time to think about things, and meet back at the hotel in two days time if both want to resume their relationship.

Dean and Cas finally find the factory likely to hold Samandriel, but its demon guards would prove too much to handle. Instead, Castiel zaps them over to a freighter holding a disheveled Kevin, who has spent weeks translating his half of the tablet to no avail. Castiel leaves to gather materials for more of Kevin’s demon-incinerating bombs, while Dean fields a call from a distressed and wagon-slipping Benny, whom he can’t help at the moment.

Crowley visits the factory at Viggo’s insistence, and realizes that Samandriel’s involuntary chants are kind of “factory settings” for angels, which may contain secrets the angels themselves don’t consciously know. Back on the freighter, Castiel returns with the necessary materials as well as Sam, asking the brothers to stow their crap for the moment.

Sam, Dean and Castiel  approach the factory at night, Castiel for the moment unable to enter due to the presence of angel sigils. Sam and Dean fight their way inside, defeating demons and destroying sigils, all the while Crowley races to uncover any useful information from Samandriel’s words. The boys manage to make it to the final door, but Samandriel’s torture begins to have a strange effect on Cas, giving him visions of Naomi and reducing him to a cowering whimper. Inside, Crowley finally learns from Samandriel of the existence of an angel tablet, much like the one designed to banish demons to hell.

The boys finally make it through the door, and kill the remaining demons as Castiel revives and frees Samandriel, taking him outside. Samandriel refuses to return to heaven, his knowledge of the tablet and the mysterious Naomi now awakened, as Naomi herself exerts her influence over Castiel. Despite his unconscious objections, Castiel does as Naomi orders and kills Samandriel for talking, telling Sam and Dean he had to do it out of self-defense. The brothers sense something wrong with Castiel given his eerily calm demeanor and bleeding eye, but the angel departs to return Samandriel’s body to heaven.

Later, after angel-proofing the cabin, Sam and Dean wonder aloud what could have caused Castiel’s strange behavior. With no leads, the brothers make up about Amelia, and Sam goes for a walk to determine what he should do. Dean finally calls back Benny, who remains kill-free for the moment, but Dean informs his vampire pal they shouldn’t keep in contact anymore.

Finally, Amelia shows up to Sam’s motel room, only to find it empty, as the two brothers recline in their cabin and watch TV together over beers. Roll credits.

However cryptically, 'Supernatural' got back down to business tonight with "Torn and Frayed," providing at least temporary caps to the Benny and Amelia stories while moving forward with the angel and tablet plots. The mysterious Naomi has been revealed as much more sinister than she seems, while the playing field has been leveled as far as banishing either angels or demons from the Earth.

On the whole, we liked the reserved approach "Torn and Frayed" took toward restoring the relationship between the brothers, giving them actual choices to remain at one another's sides rather than obligations. Surely the Benny and Amelia stories will resurface, but for now it feels good to have the band back together, as well as the show itself.

Did you get your fill of spooky ‘Supernatural’ action?  What did you think about "Torn and Frayed?" Join us again next week for an all-new episode recap of ‘Supernatural’ episode "LARP and the Real Girl" on The CW!