The Doctor Strange trailer debuted on Jimmy Kimmel Live! back in April, so it’s only fitting the late-night host would get more exclusive access to the latest Marvel hero. And by “exclusive,” we don’t exactly mean “hire the Sorcerer Supreme for children’s birthday parties,” but well, here we are.

Coinciding with the official Doctor Strange premiere, Kimmel called on Benedict Cumberbatch to don his best blue robes, Cloak of Levitation, Eye of Agamotto and that American accent you’ll never quite get used to. Stephen Strange has about as much patience for children as you’d expect, but is apparently a real … well, wizard with balloon animals.

Doctor Strange won’t officially hit theaters (or children’s parties) until November 4, but early reviews of Marvel’s latest Phase 3 movie are at least trending positive. You can stay tuned for more from the movie itself, and try not to get banished to any volcanic hellfire dimensions in the meantime.

More From ScreenCrush